# Conversation Log — Part VI — Replay It Over Syncthing · Steps 39–47 (turns 68–76) > [⬅ Previous: Part V](05-part-V.md) · [Index](../conv.md) · [Next: Part VII ➡](07-part-VII.md) > > All parts: [Setup & Step 0](00-setup-and-step-0.md) · [Part I](01-part-I.md) · [Part II](02-part-II.md) · [Part III](03-part-III.md) · [Part IV](04-part-IV.md) · [Part V](05-part-V.md) · **Part VI** · [Part VII](07-part-VII.md) --- ## [68] Student > no, i'll do each step **Tutor:** Offer of shortcuts withdrawn and recorded as a standing preference. Opened Part VI and set up Step 39: copy `05-dynamic-filesystem` to the server, repoint the container at it, clear the board, run sensor on the laptop and the two dynamic services in the container, then `Configure.java`. ## [69] Student > 2minutes and still nothing, don't know what went wrong (`Configure.java` printed "Wired: consoleIn -> rot13 -> consoleOut" on the laptop; the two `docker exec` commands on the server appeared to return.) ## [69] Tutor — actions taken - Read the laptop replica: `rot13/inbox` and `consoleOut/inbox` each held a `TOPIC` (02:29:15), `consoleIn/outbox` held the input (02:29:33), and **`rot13/outbox` was empty** — so ROT13 produced nothing. - Gave three ordered checks: container running and whether the `TOPIC` reached `/srv/syncthing/course-message-board/rot13/inbox/`; a write probe inside the container (the `--user` change being the prime suspect, as in Part III); and watching one service start in the foreground to see whether it stays attached. ## [70] Student > skip temp step 39, serv is busy with syncthing **Tutor:** Step 39 parked with a bookmark — when the server is free, check first whether the server's `rot13/inbox` ever receives the `TOPIC`. Moved on to Step 40. ## [71] Student > that means there is no information processing of our architecture performing on the data, but that doesn't mean that the data doesn't go through several process to travel from input -> rot13 **Tutor:** ✅ the step's point. Sharpened the distinction: a **transport hop** (Syncthing, even a relay) adds no participant that knows the topology and contradicts nothing; an **architectural hop** (a mediator of ours) adds a component that must know both names and sits in the availability chain. The honest claim is about knowledge and reaction, not about packets. ## [72] Student > i'd say that the text part are Event, text has been entered, text has been rot13ed, but route are created betwwen process, topic messages are sent **Tutor:** ✅ `TEXT` messages are Events, with the past-tense naming the step suggests (`ConsoleIn/E/text`, `ROT13/E/crypted`). `ROUTE` and `TOPIC` are **Intent**: they report nothing and describe nothing currently true, they request behaviour. Named the trap: publishing an Intent is itself something that happened, but classification follows the message's content, not its existence. ## [73] Student > we can imagine a process that verify that everyhting is correctly wired, in this case this process would asked to rot13 "are you subsrcibed to consolein?" or "what are your subscriptions?" which display the current state of the subscription of rot13 **Tutor:** Right content, wrong shape: *asking* is a call, and a call needs the asker to know the component and to wait. Status is **published** — `ROT13/S/subscriptions` whenever the wiring changes — so the reader needs a topic, not a component, and ROT13 never learns who audits it. Forward link to Step 71, retained Status vs non-retained Events. Added the division of labour: Event = happened (useless if you were not listening), Status = true now (what a newcomer needs), Intent = please make it so. ## [74] Student > consoleIn is the writer for its outbox, rot13 for rot13/outbox **Tutor:** ✅ ownership correct. Re-asked the second half with Step 47's distinction in hand: UUIDs prevent filename collisions, writer authority decides who owns a logical resource, and the rule bites hardest for Status. ## [75] Student > a subscriber can't know which component published the event ## [76] Student > i have 2 .msg inside the rot13/inbox ## [76] Tutor — actions taken - Read the laptop replica: every mailbox now holds two files. `rot13/inbox` and `consoleOut/inbox` hold two `TOPIC` Intents each (`Configure.java` was run twice, 00:29:15 and 00:35:19 UTC), `consoleIn/outbox` two `TEXT hello`, and `rot13/outbox` **two `TEXT uryyb`** — so the server's ROT13 did run. - Local arrival times: input at 02:35:12, the two results at 04:11:28.797 and .893 — a late batch, 96 ms apart. ## [76] Tutor — reply Step 39 is closed: the distributed dynamic version works. `consoleOut/inbox` carries **Intent only** — no payload copy, where the mediated version held a full copy of every message — and the count is 2 application publications per input, the Intents being published once per configuration. The late batch is replication latency, the transport characteristic Step 23 warned about; the student explained it afterwards as Syncthing being saturated from 23:00 to 05:00, which fits the evidence. Ledger: mediated distributed 4 publications / 5 processes in the data path; dynamic local 2 / 3; dynamic distributed 2 / 3. **Progress record** - Current step: Part VI complete → Part VII - Last observed result: distributed dynamic run verified from the board - Unresolved problem: none - Next action: Step 48 — make the case *for* a mediator --- > [⬅ Previous: Part V](05-part-V.md) · [Index](../conv.md) · [Next: Part VII ➡](07-part-VII.md) > > All parts: [Setup & Step 0](00-setup-and-step-0.md) · [Part I](01-part-I.md) · [Part II](02-part-II.md) · [Part III](03-part-III.md) · [Part IV](04-part-IV.md) · [Part V](05-part-V.md) · **Part VI** · [Part VII](07-part-VII.md)